Taking DNF or tanking a round so it doesn't count on your rating

Started by Mukey, July 18, 2006, 10:47:47 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Mukey

Ok, this has come up a few times this year...

Saw someone I know on Saturday not play the last hole & took a DNF. I can only assume that was to "protect" that person's rating. WHY? Even if your rating drops you can always play up, so besides "braggin" rights to your current rating I can't see the advantage of this. Your rating IS your ability vs. the course. Look at my rating & you'll see I've been dropping all year.  :o I still won't play Rec even if my rating falls low enough in September and I would only assume that someone whos been playing Advanced would keep playing Advanced even if their rating dropped a bit below 915.

I just think it's kinda vain. Who cares what your rating is? If you're that worried about it you should just play un-sanctioned events.

Just my $0.02.

Bruce Brakel

Whether it is vanity, insecurity, immaturity or whatever, it certainly does not reflect well on the player.  I noticed that he did that.  I wanted to make sure that he did not break a bone or pass out or something. 
Play Mokena Big D Doubles
September 11, 2011

Bruce Brakel

Would anyone think worse of me if I turned in a score for that round so he WOULD get a rating?   >:   :o
Play Mokena Big D Doubles
September 11, 2011

ninjaboy076

Quote from: bruce_brakel on July 18, 2006, 11:43:10 AM
Would anyone think worse of me if I turned in a score for that round so he WOULD get a rating? >: :o

no sir
Andy Filipiak
PDGA# 28791
Discontinuum Bag Tag:  #68
shirt seen above made completely out of duct tape, including the unicorn

stpitner

Quote from: bruce_brakel on July 18, 2006, 11:43:10 AM
Would anyone think worse of me if I turned in a score for that round so he WOULD get a rating?   >:   :o

lol, give him a 7 like you would for someone that missed the first round.
PDGA #30192
2012 Bag Tag #23

Need plastic?  Visit www.paperorplasticsports.com!
Our Official Apparel

Mike Clark

Quote from: Drathe on July 18, 2006, 10:47:47 AM
Ok, this has come up a few times this year...

Saw someone I know on Saturday not play the last hole & took a DNF. I can only assume that was to "protect" that person's rating. WHY? Even if your rating drops you can always play up, so besides "braggin" rights to your current rating I can't see the advantage of this. Your rating IS your ability vs. the course. Look at my rating & you'll see I've been dropping all year.  :o I still won't play Rec even if my rating falls low enough in September and I would only assume that someone whos been playing Advanced would keep playing Advanced even if their rating dropped a bit below 915.

I just think it's kinda vain. Who cares what your rating is? If you're that worried about it you should just play un-sanctioned events.

Just my $0.02.

Dont give the guy too hard of a time. If it wasn't for him I would have finished DFL. ;D

JK. As far as I am concerned I did finish DFL and no one can take that away from me.

You would have to drag my corpse off the course before I would not finish.

O0

Mike S

#27580